the good risk/reward trade is bar2.
short stop is at 1056.5, but stop is 1059.25, that's too much for scalp to the ES gap. normally people use 2 points as absolute stop.
In this case, shorts' stop is 1058.5, enter short at 1058.25, stop is 1059.25, target is ES gap 1055.5.
Tomorrow has two major events, one is GDP number, the other is Ben's speak. It's hard to speculate how the market will response to such a one-two punch. It could be the GDP number is bad but Ben gives investors hope, or GDP number is good but Ben disappointed investors.